What is it about particular anthologies that move me? The last one that shook me up was Conductors of Chaos (Picador, 1996)–(Christ!–over ten years ago, and my copy is turning to curry powder as I pull it from the shelf!). Other great ones: The New American Poetry, of course, Rothenberg’s The Revolution of the Word, and his big door-stoppers from the U. of California Press, Shaking the Pumpkin, The Book of the Book. Carruth’s The Voice That Is Great Within Us. Why did I dig these books so? I think it was because there was a sense of discovery about the poets/ the poems in these books. AND THEY ALL HAD DISTINCTIVE VOICES.
There’s a particular monster from–Norse?–Northern European?–mythology that sums up what I have to say about the poets of the anthologies I yawn over: imagine a trine of bodies –be they ever so beautiful–passing a single eye back and forth between them. They take turns fitting the eye into the single socket in their foreheads in order to SEE. Interchangeable vision/ interchangeable voices. Example: An anthology of AMERICAN POETS OF THE 90′S from a big press I purchased way back when–and the whole book turned into a mannered, affected, cookie-cutter yawn. Ah yes, and add a dash of PRECIOUSNESS as well.
Conductors of Chaos gave me Caroline Bergvall, Brian Catling, Kelvin Corcoran, Andrew Duncan, Bill Griffiths, Allen Fisher, Alan Halsey (!), Lee harwood, John James, Barry MacSweeney (!), Geraldine Monk (!), Doug Oliver, Maggie O’Sullivan, J. H. Prynne, Peter Riley, Nicholas Moore, Grace Lake (!), Chris Torrance (!), Denise Riley (!) and the editor himself, Ian Sinclair, whose work I caught up with in a small blue Penguin anthology. Not only are these names, these are also DISTINCTIVE VOICES that gave me permission to work and to experiment in new modes of writing. I think that’s what I seek in an anthology: PERMISSION TO DO, new tools for the tool box, new stories of a life to mull over and imagine as well.
The saddest thing about Open Field: whole swathes that appear to have been written by the same person under assumed names. The same bag of tricks opened and shaken out with a little tired TAAADAAAA and a drum-roll, the same associations, the same mannerisms, even the same line breaks.
Where is the permission to enter something/ do something new?
Where is it for this anthology?
That’s the big question.
We’re still looking for it at 4:47 a.m. while Japan stirs and the old men line up at the Shin-Urayasu bridge for some fishing before the sun comes up.