| Leonard Cohen’s Dear Heather |
Well, there’s no doubt that America has never been as polarized as it is presently. While the eschatological evangelicals wait anxiously for the battle of Armageddon, I picked up Cohen’s new album, Dear Heather. I’d had my eye on the reviews for the past month or so, which form a pastiche as divided as Larry King’s graphic representation of the electoral college vote.
In my opinion, Dear Heather is a delight. Cohen dedicates the album to Jack McClelland, a song to Irving Layton, and performs F.R. Scott’s poem “Villanelle for our Time”. Monster of canlit — it doesn’t get better than this!
But this album is by no means a critical darling. Bernard Perusse of the Montreal Gazette writes of the arrangements on Dear Heather: “Could someone please introduce Leonard to some actual musicians so he can ditch the Tinker-toy, Casio sound?” Perusse’s smugness belies the fact that, while Cohen’s trademark synth sound resurfaces on this album, the arrangements are full, complex, and improvisational. What I like about Leonard Cohen’s arrangements here is that, while the drums and bass play in regular time, the keyboard solos often spill over the beat, resulting in a breathless, jazzy sound. It follows that, The Winnipeg Sun doesn’t share Perusse’s assessment: “Cohen and a roster of living, breathing players invest these songs with a welcome earthiness, sincerity and depth”. Methinks Perusse didn’t listen to the album.
The Globe and Mail is a little more even-handed in their assessment:
Cohen’s musings on emptiness and creativity, in his spoken-word number “Morning Glory”, apply also to this album, in which rags appear in the same parade as robes of gold.
The Globe, however, jumps off the fence and firmly plants both feet in the anti-Heather camp: “The tunes are often just implications hanging between the chord changes and the narrow melodies of the poet’s speech.”
Parts of Dear Heather resonate in time with current events. Cohen writes in “On That Day”, itself an ambivalent response to the events of September 11:
Some people say
It’s what we deserve
For sins against g-d
For crimes in the world
I wouldn’t know
I’m just holding the fort
Since that day
They wounded New York
In the same manner L.C. reflects upon the proper response to the events that have served as prelude to the current polarization of the U.S., the critical community doesn’t quite know how to handle this album. While the left and right in America drift ever further apart, so does the critical response to Cohen’s latest. While this makes for a rather tenuous situation politically, in the world of art it’s always a welcome sign. Indeed, to paraphrase Blaise Cendrars, there’s poetry at play here!
Well, at least we don’t have to worry about Leonard Cohen. In this reviewers estimation, the Cohen empire is alive and well.
Blog 




